Fantasy Baseball Trade: Who wins?

Thats a tough one. Miguel Cabrera and Manny both have attitude problems, but it usually doesnt affect their stats. Liriano is a huge question mark. Oswalt is a proven pitcher who does solid every year. In a default league without the XBH i would probably stay with Aramis Ichiro and Roy. The XBH thing makes me lean more toward Manny and Cabrera because they get plenty every year.